When a child struggles with a math problem or a difficult reading passage, it is often assumed that their ability to keep going—or their tendency to give up—is a fixed part of their personality. However, new research suggests that persistence and resilience are not innate "character traits" but active parts of the learning process that can be nurtured and developed.

According to a major systematic review (Sparks et al., 2025) which synthesized findings from 74 studies on K–12 education, academic success depends less on a child’s "natural" grit and more on how tasks are designed and how adults respond to failure.

Persistence is a learned process

The research proposes a clear definition of persistence: sustained effort toward completing a goal-directed task despite difficulty. Crucially, the study found that persistence only exists when four elements are present:

• A clear task.
• A genuine challenge.
• Sustained effort.
• Eventual completion.

For parents and educators, this means that if a task is too easy, the child isn’t practicing persistence. If it is impossibly hard, they aren’t learning to persist—they are learning to fail. The "sweet spot" is a challenge that requires effort but remains achievable.

The necessity of "productive struggle"

In the early stages of learning—whether it’s reading, mathematics, or complex problem-solving—the process is naturally effortful. Before a skill becomes "automatic" or "fluent," the brain must work through uncertainty and repeated errors.

This is known as productive struggle. Research in cognitive science shows that students who are required to think hard and work through uncertainty develop a deeper, longer-lasting understanding than those who experience only "smooth success." As Professor Dylan Wiliam notes, doing things in unfamiliar ways leads to learning that is better connected to existing knowledge and remembered for longer.

Persistence vs. resilience: What is the difference?

While the terms are often used interchangeably, the research makes an important distinction:

• Persistence is the ability to keep going while the task is still in front of you.
• Resilience is the ability to recover productively after a setback or a temporary failure.

A child may persist for a while but, after failing, might disengage permanently. This is persistence without resilience. A resilient learner is one who falters, adjusts their strategy, and returns to the task.

The role of "affect-aware" feedback

How adults respond to a child's struggle determines whether that child develops resilience. The review found that students are more likely to recover from errors when:

• Mistakes are treated as information, not as a judgment of ability.
• Adults respond calmly and strategically rather than with urgency or alarm.
• Feedback is "affect-aware," meaning it acknowledges the child's frustration or boredom and helps them adjust their emotional state to stay engaged.

Key takeaways for parents and educators

To empower children to become persistent and resilient learners, we should focus on:

• Task design: Ensure challenges are "stretch" goals—just beyond the child’s current comfort zone.
• Focusing on strategy: Praise the way a child approaches a problem rather than their speed or "natural" intelligence.
• Normalizing struggle: Remind children that the "grapple" is a temporary and necessary part of the learning journey.

By treating persistence and resilience as skills to be practiced rather than traits a child is born with, we can create an environment where every student feels capable of working through difficulty to reach their goals.

Picture: Persistence is a learned process (ChildUp.com / Gemini)

READ THE ORIGINAL ARTICLE